I own the XD .45ACP among your choices. Couldn't say enough good stuff without giving you a thesis.
However, if I was in your situation, I'd look into a quality, reasonably priced 1911. The main reason: Everybody's gotta have a 1911 in their inventory.
Springer's Mil Spec, Kimber Pro or Ultra Carry comes to mind. I don't know what your price range is and there are several other variables to consider in your purchase. Those are just a couple that I'd consider first.