Quote:
|
Ask an experienced man if he'd rather go into a gunfight with a .45 or a .22 LR.
|
This is an attempt to deflect attention from your claim that there were good studies out there showing that caliber choice makes a significant difference in the outcome of real-world gunfights.
After we clear that up, we can move on to other types of "evidence".
Quote:
|
First of course there was Thompson-LaGardia.
|
Thompson Lagarde. They shot primarily bovines.
Quote:
|
Then there was Marshall and Sanow's material. Finally there was the goat shooting, was it Fackler?
|
M&S were less than rigorous in their data collection and analysis techniques and their results are generally considered to have been totally discredited. The Strasbourg Goat study can't be proven to have ever even taken place.
In any event, with the exception of M&S, none of those had anything to do with looking at gunfight outcomes.
Quote:
|
This can of worms sure has a lot of worms!
|
The topic is only complicated if one chooses to believe that a significant effect can be impossible to detect in the real world.
